Jump to content

Stanley Kubrick: Difference between revisions

From Flerf Wiki
Float the cards and split the face comparison
Compare the face: late Christiane portrait, Cruise/Kidman EWS stills with dates/sources, real-interview YT+thumb, family/estate links
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 21: Line 21:
This is Kubrick. The hairline is in the frame.
This is Kubrick. The hairline is in the frame.


[[File:Kubrick_real_interview.jpg|frame|center|link=https://www.youtube.com/shorts/OEWQ8BEZaLo|Stanley Kubrick.]]
[[File:Kubrick_real_interview.jpg|center|800px|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcZTYMpI7Bw|Stanley Kubrick talking (real).]]
 
Late portrait, about January to February 1999, credited to Christiane Kubrick / PA-AP. His beard is neat and well kept. The fake video beard is not. The voice in real clips of him talking is not close to the actor in ''Shooting Stanley Kubrick''.
 
[[File:Kubrick_Christiane_AP_PA_c1999.jpg|center|800px|link=https://static01.nyt.com/library/film/061699kubrick.15.jpg|Stanley Kubrick, late portrait by Christiane Kubrick (c. Jan-Feb 1999). Source linked.]]
 
=== With Cruise and Kidman (Eyes Wide Shut, 1996-98) ===
Real late-1990s Kubrick on the ''Eyes Wide Shut'' shoot with Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman. Dates below are shoot years (release was July 1999).
 
[[File:EWS_Kubrick_Cruise_ManuelHarlan.jpg|center|800px|link=https://theasc.com/article/a-sword-in-the-bed-eyes-wide-shut/|Kubrick with Tom Cruise on Eyes Wide Shut. Photo: Manuel Harlan / ASC. Shoot 1996-98.]]
 
[[File:EWS_Kubrick_Kidman_outdoors.jpg|center|800px|link=http://www.archiviokubrick.it/opere/Film/ews/fotoscena/sk-nicole1.jpg|Kubrick with Nicole Kidman during Eyes Wide Shut, spring/summer ~1997-98. Source: ArchivioKubrick sk-nicole1.]]
 
[[File:EWS_Kubrick_Cruise_Kidman_catering.jpg|center|800px|link=http://www.archiviokubrick.it/opere/Film/ews/fotoscena/sk-tom-nicole1.jpg|Kubrick, Tom Cruise, and Nicole Kidman on a break (catering tent), Eyes Wide Shut shoot ~1996-98. Manuel Harlan / Ronald Grant (Archivio sk-tom-nicole1).]]


=== The fakes ===
=== The fakes ===
Line 29: Line 42:
The finished piece. This is the one passed around as a confession.
The finished piece. This is the one passed around as a confession.


[[File:Kubrick_fake_interview.jpg|frame|center|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbGNj4US8ig|Tom Mayk in the cut interview.]]
[[File:Kubrick_fake_interview.jpg|center|800px|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbGNj4US8ig|Tom Mayk in the cut interview.]]


==== The raw footage ====
==== The raw footage ====
The tape from before the cut. The interviewer is still directing him. Comments on that upload mark the spots.
The tape from before the cut. The interviewer is still directing him. Comments on that upload mark the spots.


[[File:Kubrick_raw_footage.jpg|frame|center|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA|Tom Mayk, raw. The interviewer is still in the room.]]
[[File:Kubrick_raw_footage.jpg|center|800px|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA|Tom Mayk, raw. The interviewer is still in the room.]]


* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA&t=1452s 24:12]. "It's common sense, Tom."
* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA&t=1452s 24:12]. "It's common sense, Tom."
Line 40: Line 53:
* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA&t=4770s 1:19:30]. He tells the actor how to move, and how to imitate Kubrick. The directions are still going at [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA&t=4773s 1:19:33].
* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA&t=4770s 1:19:30]. He tells the actor how to move, and how to imitate Kubrick. The directions are still going at [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOZ_02nozaA&t=4773s 1:19:33].
* The voice is not Kubrick's. Take off the hair and the beard and the face is not his at that age. Half the face stays hidden.
* The voice is not Kubrick's. Take off the hair and the beard and the face is not his at that age. Half the face stays hidden.
* Kubrick's widow said this is not him.


A few more links:
=== Family and estate ===
His widow, Christiane Kubrick, and the estate rejected the tape in 2015.


* [https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-kubrick-moon/fact-check-actor-playing-stanley-kubrick-discusses-staging-moon-landing-idUSL1N37S29A Reuters fact check]
* [https://www.reuters.com/article/fact-check/actor-playing-stanley-kubrick-discusses-staging-moon-landing-idUSL1N37S29A Reuters] quotes Christiane (via a Black Bag interview that year): "The interview is a lie, Stanley Kubrick has never been interviewed by T. Patrick Murray the whole story is made up, fraudulent & untrue."
* [https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/false-stanley-kubrick-faked-moon-landings/ Snopes], 11 December 2015, and [https://fullfact.org/online/stanley-kubrick-moon-landing-fake/ Full Fact] give that same sentence to a spokesperson for her. Full Fact says the spokesperson told Gawker.
* [https://uk.news.yahoo.com/stanley-kubrick-estate-rubbishes-confession-143113320.html Yahoo / coverage of the estate response]
* [https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-kubrick-moon/fact-check-actor-playing-stanley-kubrick-discusses-staging-moon-landing-idUSL1N37S29A Reuters fact check (alternate URL)]
* [https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7f1g9t Dailymotion]
* [https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7f1g9t Dailymotion]



Latest revision as of 13:00, 5 October 2026

Moon landing deniers are not truthers. If they were they would investigate things. They are easily fooled by intentional fakes like the fake Stanley Kubrick "confession video". It's from a movie called Shooting Stanley Kubrick in 2015. The actor playing Kubrick is Tom Mayk.

The website for the fake documentary gives it away. It claims the interview was May 1999 and that Kubrick died 3 days after the interview. But no flerf will ever ask themselves "when did Kubrick die?" I'll leave it to you, dear reader, to ask and answer this question for yourself. Ironically, the correct date is on the web page.

In the raw footage from the faked interview the director is coaching the actor how to answer. The interviewer refers to the actor by name, "Tom".

Stanley Kubrick was a perfectionist. He knew how to mic and light people. The subject of this video, the person being interviewed, does not have a mic. Why would Stanley Kubrick, a professional at micing people, not insist on a mic on himself? Why would he allow the lighting to be so bad? Why would he allow someone to call him "Tom"?

Since flat earthers are anti-truthers, they will never watch the raw footage. It contradicts their preselected conclusion.

The interview is posted below. Run away flerfs. This will hurt you.

Compare the face

Look for yourself. Start with Kubrick. The bags under the eyes. The eyebrows. The rest of the face. Then the hairline. The fake clips stay in close-up and crop the hairline out. A hairline that does not match is the kind of difference you cannot talk past. They are not the same person, and that crop is doing the hiding.

Kubrick

This is Kubrick. The hairline is in the frame.

Stanley Kubrick talking (real).
Stanley Kubrick talking (real).

Late portrait, about January to February 1999, credited to Christiane Kubrick / PA-AP. His beard is neat and well kept. The fake video beard is not. The voice in real clips of him talking is not close to the actor in Shooting Stanley Kubrick.

Stanley Kubrick, late portrait by Christiane Kubrick (c. Jan-Feb 1999). Source linked.
Stanley Kubrick, late portrait by Christiane Kubrick (c. Jan-Feb 1999). Source linked.

With Cruise and Kidman (Eyes Wide Shut, 1996-98)

Real late-1990s Kubrick on the Eyes Wide Shut shoot with Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman. Dates below are shoot years (release was July 1999).

Kubrick with Tom Cruise on Eyes Wide Shut. Photo: Manuel Harlan / ASC. Shoot 1996-98.
Kubrick with Tom Cruise on Eyes Wide Shut. Photo: Manuel Harlan / ASC. Shoot 1996-98.
Kubrick with Nicole Kidman during Eyes Wide Shut, spring/summer ~1997-98. Source: ArchivioKubrick sk-nicole1.
Kubrick with Nicole Kidman during Eyes Wide Shut, spring/summer ~1997-98. Source: ArchivioKubrick sk-nicole1.
Kubrick, Tom Cruise, and Nicole Kidman on a break (catering tent), Eyes Wide Shut shoot ~1996-98. Manuel Harlan / Ronald Grant (Archivio sk-tom-nicole1).
Kubrick, Tom Cruise, and Nicole Kidman on a break (catering tent), Eyes Wide Shut shoot ~1996-98. Manuel Harlan / Ronald Grant (Archivio sk-tom-nicole1).

The fakes

Both of these are Tom Mayk in Shooting Stanley Kubrick. The frame stays on the beard and the glasses.

The cut interview

The finished piece. This is the one passed around as a confession.

Tom Mayk in the cut interview.
Tom Mayk in the cut interview.

The raw footage

The tape from before the cut. The interviewer is still directing him. Comments on that upload mark the spots.

Tom Mayk, raw. The interviewer is still in the room.
Tom Mayk, raw. The interviewer is still in the room.
  • 24:12. "It's common sense, Tom."
  • 36:06, 36:13, and 36:50. He is feeding the actor lines. At 36:50 he says he is just giving lines, then "look over here, look over here." Pages are turning. They are reading it.
  • 1:19:30. He tells the actor how to move, and how to imitate Kubrick. The directions are still going at 1:19:33.
  • The voice is not Kubrick's. Take off the hair and the beard and the face is not his at that age. Half the face stays hidden.

Family and estate

His widow, Christiane Kubrick, and the estate rejected the tape in 2015.

See also